The D.C. Jail’s food has been a health hazard for too long

A new lawsuit and a DOJ investigation might finally force them to fix it.

Images of black mice inside a food tray
(Via class action lawsuit against the D.C. Jail)

Linnell Shelton spent Ramadan in the D.C. jail this year. After fasting all day, he opened his dinner tray and discovered a dead mouse in his rice. A jail doctor later told him the mouse “looked like it had been boiled.” The experience so disturbed Shelton that he did not eat for several days afterward, according to an account of the incident in a class action lawsuit filed last month. 

The suit’s six plaintiffs, all current or former residents of the jail, allege that the D.C. Department of Corrections served them vermin, including mice and cockroaches, in their food. The DOC has continually denied the allegations despite multiple complaints and photographic evidence, the lawsuit says. In Mr. Shelton’s case, the suit alleges that an investigating officer accused him of placing the mouse in the tray himself and threatened to send him to segregation. 

None of the details in the lawsuit surprised me, as someone who has spent time in the jail. In 2015-2016, I was incarcerated in the jail for nearly a year, eating meals provided by Aramark Correctional Services, the jail’s food service contractor to this day. One day, I watched a man across the table uncover half a dead mouse — the back half — in his dinner entree. Spoiled foods like moldy bread and chunky milk were a regular feature of our meals.

These details shouldn’t surprise the D.C. DOC, either. All the way back in 2013, District health inspectors documented an “active infestation of vermin/pests throughout the facility,” and noted unsanitary conditions in areas where food was prepared. In 2019, a D.C. Auditor’s report noted that D.C.’s Department of Health has repeatedly cited Aramark for failing to comply with the city’s food safety regulations, including for failing to keep surfaces clean, failing to hold food at the proper temperature, and failing to “control pests in the culinary area.” A 2025 auditor’s report noted that residents and jail staff have reported the presence of bugs, rodents, and screws in the food. 

Advocates have been trying to do something about this for years. In 2023, the local coalition of community organizations that I lead surveyed more than 300 people inside the jail, and about 70% of them told us they had been served spoiled or rotten food. Coalition members have testified at D.C. Council hearings, met with DOC staff, and written letters to our elected leaders. Despite so much evidence of clearly inhumane conditions inside the jail, too little has been done. 

But now the issue has caught the attention of the Department of Justice. Days after the class action lawsuit was filed, the DOJ announced it would investigate the D.C. Jail for potential Constitutional violations, naming issues with medical care, sanitation and inadequate nutrition. 

D.C. doesn’t have to wait for the courts or the DOJ. The council and the incoming mayor have all the information they need to take action now. Officials should move as quickly as possible to remediate the jail’s pervasive pest infestations once and for all. The city should reject renewal of Aramark’s contract, given these serious failures. D.C. has urban farms and local producers and food hubs that would likely be happy to sell fresh foods to the jail. We should look to other cities for examples of success — New York City has passed revised food standards that apply to city jails much larger than the District’s.

In 2024 the D.C. Council passed FRESH STARTS, legislation requiring more nutritious dietary standards, plant based meal alternatives, monthly sanitation and food safety reports, and other improvements to food safety and nutrition in the D.C. Jail. But the law wasn’t  implemented because the council has not fully funded it. Allocating full funding is the next step in improving the jail’s conditions. It’s the city’s job to ensure that whoever feeds people at the jail meets clear standards, has inspection results publicized, pays real penalties for violations, and answers for what ends up on trays. 

The D.C. government has had many years of warning that this moment would come. It’s no secret that the dilapidated jail is providing profoundly substandard living conditions to its occupants. Contaminated and inedible food is one of the more obvious manifestations of their dehumanizing treatment. It’s about time local officials showed urgency in fixing this injustice, which is being enacted upon residents of our community every day. 

Daniel Rosen coordinates the D.C. Jail Food Working Group and is the founder and Executive Director of the Carceral Nutrition Project. He has lived in the District for over 30 years and spent almost a year in the D.C. Jail.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to The 51st.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.

Join