D.C. is poised to pass major utility reforms. Will they get gas and electric bills under control?

The GRID Act seeks to limit utility companies’ profits, regulate third-party suppliers, and update the Public Service Commission, among other changes.

Power lines and buildings represent the struggles D.C. residents have with utility affordability.
(Illustration by George Kevin Jordan)

Soaring gas and electric bills electrified the city’s elections and jumpstarted a debate about how policymakers can address a huge piece of the District’s affordability crisis. After months of debate, the D.C. Council has its answer, advancing its most sweeping suite of utility reforms in years.

Pepco and Washington Gas are used to getting their way in the Wilson Building — the utilities count a host of former councilmembers and staffers as part of their high-dollar lobbying operations — so the GRID Act is unusual for how directly it challenges their power. It sets the stage for regulators to limit the size of their yearly profits in order to disincentivize them from raising rates or launching costly infrastructure projects, as well as imposing stricter regulations on third-party suppliers, making changes to the utilities commission, and a number of other reforms.

Written by Ward 6 Councilmember Charles Allen and co-introduced by six of his colleagues, the bill passed on a first vote last week and is expected to take a second one in December. But there are real questions about whether, and how quickly, the reforms can deliver relief for residents. 

“They’re putting these huge data center warehouses out in the suburbs and it’s causing everyone's prices to go up, whether you're in Maryland, D.C., or Virginia,” said former councilmember David Grosso, who’s been lobbying against some of the GRID Act’s provisions on behalf of third-party suppliers. “And I don't think that this is going to solve that problem.”

Even some of the bill’s proponents believe it’s far from sufficient to address the scale of the problem, acknowledging that the city can’t unilaterally resolve prices driven up by the war in Iran and construction of data centers. And the provisions won’t take effect in time to stop rate increases immediately, particularly with more on the way in the coming months. But they don’t see that as a reason for the city to sit on its hands. 

Many of the changes have been on environmentalists’ wishlists for years, particularly those aimed at overhauling the District’s Public Service Commission, which regulates Pepco and Washington Gas. 

“We have had terrible oversight from the Council for a decade, we have had terrible regulation from the Public Service Commission for a decade or more, and the result has been skyrocketing electricity and gas prices,” says Mark Rodeffer, political committee chair for the D.C. Sierra Club. “It really is time to rein the utilities in.”

Naturally, this has attracted pushback from the utilities, which have been urging councilmembers to amend the bill before it passes, particularly the piece that could impact profits. It’s unlikely they’ll convince the Council to reject the legislation entirely — it passed unanimously — but the next few weeks before a final vote will likely be full of debates that could reshape some of its key provisions.

“These are not nonprofit companies; they want to be able to make a profit, and so they are going to argue for their own self interest,” Allen said at a Council meeting last week. “There is nothing wrong with that…but everybody feels that utility rates have gone up dramatically, and we want to do something about it.”

Regulating the regulators

One of the key theories behind the GRID Act is that the Public Service Commission, a three-member body appointed by the mayor and confirmed by the Council, hasn’t had the right tools to bring prices down and hasn’t been made up of the right people.

To that end, the bill is designed to speed up the PSC’s review processes for the connection of renewable energy sources to the electrical grid and force the utilities to demonstrate clear consumer benefits before approving major infrastructure projects. (The latter has been a particularly thorny topic in recent years, as Washington Gas has tried to steer through pipe replacement projects that many environmentalists believe are overinflated compared to their actual need.) 

The bill also temporarily bars the PSC from approving multiyear rate increases, after the D.C. appeals court ruled the commission rushed through its approval of a Pepco plan that would’ve generated an extra $123 million for the utility over the next few years.

And it takes aim at the makeup of the commission, a perpetual complaint of climate advocates. They’ve argued for years that Mayor Muriel Bowser has handed out PSC posts as political favors rather than seeking to find policy experts (as this frustration mounted, the Council passed a bill several years ago mandating commissioners actually have experience with electric grids and renewable energy). They believe this has contributed to the commission’s general deference to the utilities, and so the bill expands the commission to five members and lays out additional standards about their qualifications. 

“The commission’s priorities have been out of step with the District’s priorities for a long time,” says Claire Mills, D.C. director of the Chesapeake Climate Action Network. “They’ve long had the ability to do things that would lower utility rates and just haven’t done them.”

The changes to the PSC will be particularly meaningful as Mayor-elect Janeese Lewis George prepares to take office. She hammered the commission frequently during her campaign (accusing her top opponent, Kenyan McDuffie, of failing to exercise proper oversight) and she’ll now have the chance to reshape the body. Former chair Emile Thompson resigned earlier this year before his term was about to expire, and the current chair, Ted Trabue, is also up for reappointment, but he’s unlikely to stick around after frequently voting with Thompson to support utility rate hikes. If the GRID Act passes, Lewis George would also add two new members to the PSC as well.

Allen has already been working with her campaign chair to identify potential candidates, according to multiple sources familiar with the matter. Relatedly, Allen also included a provision in a bill removing the longstanding requirement PSC members must have lived in the city for at least three years before serving, instead requiring only that they relocate within six months of being appointed. He said last week this would broaden the pool of potential commissioners, noting this brings the law in line with residency requirements for other government agency heads.

There’s no guarantee that a new makeup of the PSC will bring prices down. Some in and around the PSC believe the commission has been unfairly scapegoated during the debate about rising prices, given factors outside its control. (Thompson pointedly noted in his resignation letter that “rising energy prices are not attributable to any one agency, group or thing.”) But Allen believes PSC reform is a necessary first step given the commission’s performance in recent years. 

“We're empowering the Public Service Commission to be able to go and try to put ratepayers first,” Allen said. “That's what they have not done for a long time.”

Cutting profit margins

One of the PSC’s biggest new responsibilities under the GRID Act would be determining whether the utilities really need to be collecting such large profits.

Right now, the utilities are allowed to earn up to 9.8 percent profits based on the rates they charge customers; the bill would direct the PSC to consider lowering it to 7 percent instead. That may seem like a relatively small change, but Mills observes that these guaranteed profits comprise between 15 and 20 percent of each customer’s monthly bill, and the city’s chief financial officer estimates the move would result in more than $50 million in savings annually across the District.

“This is something that a lot of states are looking at around the country,” Mills says. “These utilities aren’t just local companies anymore. They’re owned by big, multinational corporations, and that's just driven a much more profit-seeking approach.”

The utilities argue making such a change would come with domino effects. Even their executives admit it would likely shrink bills in the short term, but they claim it could drive up their borrowing costs on infrastructure projects moving forward. 

“If lenders or investors charge more because they see greater risk, customers may ultimately bear some of those costs,” Washington Gas executives wrote in a letter to the Council last week. Pepco lobbyists also handed out a flyer to lawmakers arguing the change would create “higher financing costs” and put its credit rating at risk, leading to “more expensive grid projects” in the future.

“To the extent we don't have access to capital, we can't make the investments we've been making to date, or in a timely manner,” says Rob Leming, Pepco’s vice president of regulatory policy and strategy. “We have concerns that we’d start to see reliability problems starting to become more prevalent. There’s a hidden cost there.”

Ward 7 Councilmember Wendell Felder said last week he was moved by those concerns, authoring an amendment calling for a study of the change instead to avoid any “unintended consequences.” 

Ward 2 Councilmember Brooke Pinto agreed, saying “I don't want to look back and say we were really well-intended capping what the equity return could be, and then, in practice, we actually degraded our utility system in a way that I know is not of interest to anyone.” 

But Allen countered that it would amount to “studying the study” since the PSC will already be evaluating whether the change makes sense. He ultimately convinced Felder to shelve his amendment, due to a lack of support among his colleagues, though it’s possible lawmakers will revisit the issue ahead of the next vote on the bill. 

“I cannot sit here and promise you that there would not be at some point potentially a [credit] downgrade, or that borrowing costs might go up,” Allen said. “But we know, based on experience, it is a fraction of what the savings are that we would help deliver for our residents and for our businesses, and that to me is what we're driving at.”

Third-party price cap

The bill also takes aim at “third-party suppliers,” which offer to sell to both residential and commercial customers instead of the utility companies.

These third parties have come under fire before for potentially abusive sales tactics, such as offering residents up-front incentives for switching over and then charging substantially higher rates. The GRID Act would set a price cap on how much they can charge above gas and electric rates established by the PSC, in addition other measures meant to protect consumers. 

“They’re gouging District residents,” Ward 5 Councilmember Zachary Parker said last week. “I met with them, and they couldn't justify why they are increasing residents' bills.”

Accordingly, those companies are also pushing hard against the bill, hiring Grosso, a councilmember-turned-lobbyist at the high-powered firm ArentFox Schiff, to plead their case. 

The argument advanced by Grosso’s client, the Retail Energy Supply Association, is that a price cap would push these third-party suppliers out of the city entirely. Frank Caliva, the association’s spokesperson, points to neighboring Maryland, which recently passed a similar cap and has seen companies abandon the market. 

Bills there have remained similarly high, he notes, as the factors driving bills higher are “global and national” in nature and not particularly relevant to the firms he represents. Instead, Caliva would support a narrower set of consumer protections, such as a more robust licensing regime for these companies to protect against “bad actors.”

“We dislike taking away choice from people,” Caliva says, noting that some third parties could offer lower rates or allow people to buy power that relies on more renewable sources.

Council Chair Phil Mendelson says he is sympathetic to some of those arguments, and pushed Allen to slightly bump up the price cap. The Council instead agreed to allow these firms to charge up to 115 percent of the gas and electric rates, instead of 110 percent.

But lawmakers seemed unwilling to abandon the cap entirely, arguing that not enough people benefit from lower rates from these firms to justify the suspicious practices and higher prices advanced by many in the market.

Allowing battery storage?   

Meanwhile, Mendelson backed an amendment last week that would allow utilities to own battery storage operations in the District. It’s a popular new development in the energy sector, allowing companies to store energy (particularly from renewable sources) generated at off-peak times and use it to meet subsequent demand surges. 

Environmentalists argue this would run afoul of a key reform passed nearly three decades ago that required the utilities to divest from their electricity-generating assets, like power plants. The idea is that the utilities should be incentivized to go into the market and buy power supply from whoever is offering the lowest price, not just rely on their own plants. 

Rodeffer believes this change would put Pepco on “both sides of the transaction” once again. He believes it’s reasonable to allow the utilities to build battery storage, but he thinks there needs to be safeguards to put them on an even playing field with other, smaller firms so they’re not privileging their own product. 

“With this provision, the government is back to its bad old ways of being in Pepco’s pocket,” Rodeffer says.

Leming, the Pepco executive, believes Rodeffer’s concerns are overblown. He contends that barring utilities from this sector would simply make it harder for them to manage the city’s energy needs effectively.

“It gives us additional tools to help manage the grid,” Leming says. “We think that's a common sense thing that we should be doing, and is a good outcome for our customers.”

Solar developers in the city, who have been particularly active in the battery storage market, believe the Council would be making a serious mistake with this provision. Nicole Rentz, director of market development and policy for New Columbia Solar, argues the move would damage "the private market before it ever takes off,” privileging the already dominant utilities in the process. 

“Creating this sort of system where the utility can play in that market too is problematic because it cuts out any competition and participation by third parties, which is, frankly, to the detriment of consumers,” Rentz says.

Leming argues that Maryland has allowed utilities into the market, without seeing negative impacts on the solar industry. But since the Council only added this provision moments before taking a first vote on the legislation, Rentz is hopeful there’s room for more refinement before the bill ultimately passes.

When will bills go down?

Even the GRID Act’s biggest boosters will admit that few of these changes could slash utility bills right away. 

Should the bill pass as expected (likely at the Council’s Dec. 1 meeting), lawmakers will still need to find about $4.6 million to fund its various provisions, according to the chief financial officer, and that can’t happen until the Council passes its new budget next year.

And while the bill does lay out timelines for many of these changes, little would be immediate. For instance, the PSC has six months after the bill passes to make changes to the size of the profits the utilities can collect. With all the administrative work required, the CFO estimates consumers wouldn’t see savings from this piece of the bill until 2028 at the earliest. The commission will also need to hire new staff and expand its capacity for undertaking some of this work, ensuring nothing about this will be particularly swift.

With some rate hikes already approved (and the price of natural gas climbing ever higher amid uncertainty in the Middle East), that means it’s a near certainty residents will start seeing even more bill increases in the near future. That amounts to a challenging reality for politicians, who can argue they’ve made substantial changes but won’t be able to point to immediate results.

This could be especially consequential for Lewis George, considering the emphasis she put on utility affordability during her campaign. She may have a mandate after her decisive primary win, but the honeymoon period may only last so long as bills climb higher.

“I think this moment and the results of [the election] showed that people are tired of hearing what government can't do, and they want to see what government can do,” Lewis George told reporters shortly after she was crowned mayor-elect. “I hope that as the year goes on, I'm able to show real impact, and people are able to see the results.”

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to The 51st.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.

Join